What's new

"Pure speculation is not probable cause."

D

Deleted User01

You basically discredited him in front of all of us. I'm pretty sure he would agree with me. But this ain't about him anymore. Talk to the Vanuatuans and see how they would like you to play it out. And then have them explain the reasons for that. We'll leave the good doctor out of this for now.
 

Bula Kava House

Portland, OR
Kava Vendor
Kava Bar Owner
Look, if noble only kava is what somehow ensures I'm able to stay in business by convincing everyone that kava is safe, I'm okay with it. Generally, though not always, it's more desirable than tudei anyway. The fact that no traditionally prepared kava, noble or tudei, has ever been implicated in liver failure or damage should cause people to question whether tudei is a red herring, but hey, can't make an omelette without breaking some eggs. It sucks, but it is what it is. Ah, that Koniak was nice.

People need to learn more about kava from a practical standpoint though, and they'll see why getting rid of tudei is difficult. Go to Vanuatu and talk to farmers, processors and exporters about tudei and the conversation is different than the one westerners are having. When I was just there I was promoting noble only planting of various cultivars, I got a lot of push back. Growers tell you about how they've been growing a certain non-noble kava for generations (not just since the European market encouraged it). They say that scientists and government officials come into the villages telling them what to grow and the response is basically, "Who the f*** are you to tell me what to grow? We've been doing this for centuries."

There are a couple ways to address this. One is convincing a people that they're wrong and these dozens of kava varieties they've developed and used are actually dangerous and they're morally obligated to grow noble. This is fruiitless. The other option, and I think vendors like Mike at Kalm and I, among a few others, are on top of this one, is telling the people we import from that we'll only pay for noble, then testing it to confirm. That's economics 101, demand affecting supply. Problem here is that the online market for drinking kava in North America is only a small portion of the Vanuatu kava exports. Many more kava vendors worldwide need to make the same demands.
 
Last edited:

Bula Kava House

Portland, OR
Kava Vendor
Kava Bar Owner
A "Noble Chemotype" can simply be produced by mixing 51% Noble varieties with 49% Tudei varieties by sample math.
Not entirely true, Mike. Combine 51% of a noble kava with a moderate level of Kavain and DHK, and a somewhat hight level of DHM (for a noble) with 49% of a tudei with a ridiculously high level of DHM and low kavain and DHK, for example, and there's a good chance you get a wacky chemotype with DHM in one of the first two positions (Clearly not noble). The chemotypes would have to work pretty well together to get a noble chemotype in your scenario. And playing devil's advocate, if you did mix two and end up with a clearly noble chemotype, there's a good chance you'd have desirable effects, along with relatively low Fk levels...

HPLC and chemotype are very useful for identifying noble, as long as results are read by someone who knows what they're looking for.
 
D

Deleted User01

@Kavasseur, I will say you didn't discredit Dr. Lebot (because you said so). Dr. Lebot is the one who has to defend his own honor, not I. That being said, please call the People in Vanuatu that are in charge of promoting the kava industry to get some guidance. I will go along with whatever they tell you. As for the Islanders who grow Tudie for cultural/religious reasons and for internal consumption, that is certainly both their right and their pocketbook. I just hope they don't try to sell it to the West as Noble. Ya see, that's when things get kinda sticky. First the Tudei farmer, then the Acetone Test, and then the Screaming.
 

Kojo Douglas

The Kavasseur
Amazing. I present a counter-argument and you immediately call for censorship and accuse me of a "disinformation campaign."

If I'm so wrong and so "alone" then what are you concerned about?
 

Bula Kava House

Portland, OR
Kava Vendor
Kava Bar Owner
I've already posted ample evidence from official sources that make it very clear that Vanuatu is absolutely against the cultivation and sale of two day kava. These documents were not written by Dr. Lebot, they represent the official stance of Vanuatu:

Vanuatu National Kava Strategy Includes Ban on Planting Tudei Kava
Vanuatu National Quality Standard for Kava Export
To be fair, right or wrong, the stance of the Vanuatu Government is what is addressed in your links. They do not speak for all in Vanuatu. Many kava growers don't really understand why they shouldn't grow and export tudei. I've encountered this multiple times in my trips. I'm also pretty sure that the standards were written based on Dr. Lebot's recommendations, even if they weren't written by him.

And I will say that as a vendor, the tudei bans have affected me. We used to sell a non-noble kava that was very popular that we called "Koniak". It was sourced from PNG but shipped from Fiji. The Fiji government eventually told my supplier that because it wasn't noble, he couldn't ship it. That's why we no longer carry that kava. Being as established as we are, with access to so many noble kava varieties, we were still able to survive and flourish. For those same reasons, I'm not willing to make a big stink about a ban on tudei, and I'm happy to adhere to the Vanuatu government's wishes and only import noble kava. I do agree with Doug though that drinking kava is safe. Period.
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted User01

Thanks @Deleted User, I knew the Vanauatuans were too smart to cut their own wrists. Then this is just an informal debate sponsored by the Kava Forums Debate Club. As long as it stays here, it shouldn't hurt anyone or any one industry. And yes, I agree, there are more dangerous drugs than Tudie. But I'm still not going to support any vendor selling Tudie though he has the right to sell whatever he wants. I'm done. Discuss amongst yourselves.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FYS

Edward

Aluballin' in the UK
Kava Vendor
To be fair, right or wrong, the stance of the Vanuatu Government is what is addressed in your links. They do not speak for all in Vanuatu. Many kava growers don't really understand why they shouldn't grow and export tudei. I've encountered this multiple times in my trips. I'm also pretty sure that the standards were written based on Dr. Lebot's recommendations, even if they weren't written by him.

And I will say that as a vendor, the tudei bans have affected me. We used to sell a non-noble kava that was very popular that we called "Koniak". It was sourced from PNG but shipped from Fiji. The Fiji government eventually told my supplier that because it wasn't noble, he couldn't ship it. That's why we no longer carry that kava. Being as established as we are, with access to so many noble kava varieties, we were still able to survive and flourish. For those same reasons, I'm not willing to make a big stink about a ban on tudei, and I'm happy to adhere to the Vanuatu government's wishes and only import noble kava. I do agree with Doug though that drinking kava is safe. Period.
I never tried koniak, maybe you had stopped selling it by the time I started drinking kava? Out of interest though what were the effects actually like? Was it actually more likely to make you feel ill the next day?
 

Bula Kava House

Portland, OR
Kava Vendor
Kava Bar Owner
I never tried koniak, maybe you had stopped selling it by the time I started drinking kava? Out of interest though what were the effects actually like? Was it actually more likely to make you feel ill the next day?
Hi @Edward. We stopped selling it a year or two ago. It was very popular. We sell a whole lot of kava, maybe more than anybody, so of course there were a few bad reviews, as there are with any kava, but they were overwhelmingly positive. We also served it at the kava bar in Portland to hundreds of people daily and they mostly raved about it as well. It was very physically relaxing. Great for pain and sleep. A little bit of a nice wash of euphoria came along with it. For as much talk as there is about the potency of tudei, it wasn't overwhelming. Any next day effects were minimal. That's the thing- Economics 101. If we sold products that made people sick we wouldn't have gotten to where we are. Demand wins every time, and this is a business of repeat customers and word of mouth.
 
Last edited:

Edward

Aluballin' in the UK
Kava Vendor
Hi @Edward. We stopped selling it a year or two ago. It was very popular. We sell a whole lot of kava, maybe more than anybody, so of course there were a few bad reviews, as there are with any kava, but they were overwhelmingly positive. We also served it at the kava bar in Portland to hundreds of people daily and they mostly raved about it as well. It was very physically relaxing. Great for pain and sleep. A little bit of a nice wash of euphoria came along with it. For as much talk as there is about the potency of tudei, it wasn't overwhelming. Any next day effects were minimal. That's the thing- Economics 101. If we sold products that made people sick we wouldn't have gotten to where we are. Demand wins every time, and this is a business of repeat customers and word of mouth.
So we can safely say that not all tu*ei kavas are created equal. I'd be interested to know what causes that kava to be more relaxing than others, is it simply more kavalactones? Could it be as simple as that? It's like GHK kavas or BKH kavas, some of those can be really strong, I'm thinking Hanakapi Ai or Nangol Noble (also stone, on that bad boy tonight and feeling good), so I know they're strong I'm not going to need 8 tbsps. 4 will probably be enough for a good session without getting too messed up. With other kavas I need more to get a similar effect or in fact you won't get a similar effect without bringing on stomach issues from the amount of root/sediment. If tu*ei kavas are just really strong versions of the same thing surely you could just limit your amount to get the desired effect?
 

TheKavaSociety

New Zealand
Kava Vendor
So we can safely say that not all tu*ei kavas are created equal. I'd be interested to know what causes that kava to be more relaxing than others, is it simply more kavalactones? Could it be as simple as that? It's like GHK kavas or BKH kavas, some of those can be really strong, I'm thinking Hanakapi Ai or Nangol Noble (also stone, on that bad boy tonight and feeling good), so I know they're strong I'm not going to need 8 tbsps. 4 will probably be enough for a good session without getting too messed up. With other kavas I need more to get a similar effect or in fact you won't get a similar effect without bringing on stomach issues from the amount of root/sediment. If tu*ei kavas are just really strong versions of the same thing surely you could just limit your amount to get the desired effect?
In terms of actual potency (kl %), tudeis are not necessarily stronger than noble. In fact, looking at the latest collection of samples submitted to the Codex Com, many tudeis were weaker than popular noble varieties. I think the idea that tudeis are stronger than noble came from the time when few people sold decent noble and tudei has always been cheaper and faster to grow than anything else.
Tudeis have much higher concentrations of DHM and DHK with the former being linked to longer-lasting sedation and nausea.
They also have considerably higher concentrations of flavokavains, which could potentially be adding to the next-day lethargy, hangovers etc.
Plus other stuff we might not fully understand or be aware of now. It's both quantitatively and qualitatively different to noble kava.

In the past some people were pushing the idea that tudei was just a stronger (quantiatively) version of noble. When it was demonstrated not be true, they changed their ads to suggest that tudei was perhaps not quantatively stronger, but it was a qualitatively more "potent" kava, often referred to as "elite kava", "kava for connoiseurs" etc, which was obviously dishonest. These days even the hardcore tudei advocates admit it's generally less pleasant and unsuitable for daily consumption due to side-effects (and not potency). E.g. "I only drink Tudei Kava once or twice every few years because I also don’t prefer its next-day effects" (Kavasseur).
 

Bula Kava House

Portland, OR
Kava Vendor
Kava Bar Owner
So we can safely say that not all tu*ei kavas are created equal. I'd be interested to know what causes that kava to be more relaxing than others, is it simply more kavalactones? Could it be as simple as that? It's like GHK kavas or BKH kavas, some of those can be really strong, I'm thinking Hanakapi Ai or Nangol Noble (also stone, on that bad boy tonight and feeling good), so I know they're strong I'm not going to need 8 tbsps. 4 will probably be enough for a good session without getting too messed up. With other kavas I need more to get a similar effect or in fact you won't get a similar effect without bringing on stomach issues from the amount of root/sediment. If tu*ei kavas are just really strong versions of the same thing surely you could just limit your amount to get the desired effect?
That is correct. Not all non-noble kavas are equal. The particular effects of any kava are caused mostly by the quantities of different kavalactones and how they interplay with each other. Some non-noble kavas you would simply want to avoid in any amount though.
 

Edward

Aluballin' in the UK
Kava Vendor
Here's my review of @Bula Kava House Koniak, which I reviewed while living in Ethiopia:

http://kavasseur.blogspot.com/2014/01/the-koniak-avalanche.html
Yep, awesome review. The laughing bit in the middle reminded me of something funny that happened in Morocco when I was there. My other 2 friends went for a massage which I didn't fancy, been to the hammam already that day. My friends Moroccan friend took me for a walk around Agadir. We were walking and talking for quite a while, sometimes in English but quite often in French because he speaks both and if I can't get something across in English I'll try French. He's a nice guy and I've met him before so didn't feel uncomfortable in his company. Anyway, I asked him what cut of meat do they use in lamb tagine, thinking like leg or whatever...he just looked at me and said, "Yeah, leg,(pause), head, stomach, whatever" and we both looked at each other and laughed like trains for a full 2 minutes. You probably had to be there.
 

Edward

Aluballin' in the UK
Kava Vendor
I think my position has always been the same, I just don't want to drink kava that's going to make me ill. I've had a few close calls with noble kava but that was more when I was pushing my boundaries and finding out what happens if I drink 12 tbps in one night (not generally good). Since then I have developed a feel for roughly how much I'm going to need to get me where I want to be. Of course it's a bit more hit and miss than that but in general I'm getting better at listening to the kava but also listening to my own body so if the first two shells hit me hard then I can leave a bit more time until the third one rather than just keep on chugging. I've gone back to mixing quite strong again so I can get 5 to 8 tbsps into 4 cups of water (and milk of course) so it can come out a bit thick but overall I just know what I'm doing better.

The trouble with tu*ei kava is that you just don't know how it's going to affect you. I'm happy to believe that there are certain tu*eis that would make you feel amazing and still give you minimal effects the next morning. Honestly labelled and sold tu*ei doesn't worry me as much because at least people have the choice. What worries me more is mixed products where you don't know what you're getting. I think if you're going to argue for the right of people to be able to buy tu*ei kava you should be equally vociferous for the people that only want to buy noble kava. I remember in kavadude's interview (btw where is kavadude? Haven't seen him for a while) with Mike from KWK. Mike said in the early days he would drink kava and sometimes get sick the next morning and sometimes not. I don't want to be in that situation, I've got to hold a job down, etc. I really want both types labelled properly and tested properly so then at least everyone has the choice. Without the testing the choice is eroded. That's what matters to me and probably plenty of other people.
 

Edward

Aluballin' in the UK
Kava Vendor
This is an excellent comment. I'd only add that it might not be enough to just label a tudei as "tudei". It's also important not to deceive one's customers. When I started my kava journey I often encountered ads and slogans suggesting that tudei was "not for beginners", "watch out - extra STRONG!", "elite kava", "VIP kava", "kava for real kava connoiseurs" (seriously, these are the actual labels). As someone who was new to the whole online kava buying I was under the impression that tudei kava was simply the best value for money. If it's just "super strong" and if it's consumed by "elites" and "connoiseurs" then why should I bother with the "weak" stuff.

Fortunately before deciding to buy some I did quite a bit of research (that was even before TK etc) and was astonished to find out that actually it's considered to be an inferior type of kava, rarely used, often referred to as "no drink kava" or "hangover kava", genetically closer to the unequivocally "undrinkable" wild kava than noble. I was also astonished to see that kava experts had been warning against it since at least the early 2000s. Even some of the earlier texts (including texts from over decades ago) referred to it as "undesriable", "unpleasant" etc. To call such kava "elite kava" or "kava for real connoiseurs" is dishonest beyond measure. Fortunately I didn't fall into that trap. Unfortunately I fell into another trap and bought a kava labelled as "noble" that likely contained wild kava, which made me physically ill. Regrettebly I shared some of that kava (without knowning about its side effects) with a more sensitive friend of mine who ended up seeking medical assistance as he couldn't stop vomiting and shitting at the same time. In light of that experience, I am not sure my friend would agree with @Kavasseur 's slogan that "ALL kava is safe".

To this day I thank kava scientists and Garry for their service. And I obviously thank those farmers and suppliers who supply pure, noble kava.
As time goes on though we're finding it a lot easier to get noble only kava. In fact you'll struggle to find a pure tu*ei kava easily to be imported to the UK because the main vendors just don't sell it. Also imagine what would happen if one of the main vendors did sell a mixed kava and that started making people ill, it would be all over the site before they knew what was happening. In that way as a community we have become very self regulating. I believe testing should be done but a lot of the kavas available now have not been tested due to funding and time constraints at TK which is fair enough. Despite that there are still a good number of vendors only selling noble kava and word of mouth does as good a job in the long run as testing.
 
Top